Can an Off-Grid Solar System Run an Incinerating Toilet?

    by Brendon Shervell||Off grid, Tiny home|6 min read

    A white toilet standing on bare ground in front of an off-grid tiny home, beside a giant dark question mark

    Yes, a well sized off-grid solar system can run a 2kW electric incinerating toilet, and a real test in a New Zealand tiny home shows it. The catch is that it only works if the battery, the inverter and the timing of when you use it are all right.

    Plenty of tiny home owners run an LPG incinerating toilet and would love to drop the gas bottle to save on ongoing costs. But a 2kW toilet is one of the biggest loads you can put on an off-grid system, so it's fair to ask whether your solar can actually keep up.

    Our friends at Ecoash, who supply Cinderella incinerating toilets in NZ, recently put that to the test in a working off-grid tiny home. Here's what they found, and what we'd take from it as the people who design these systems.

    The setup: a 13kWh tiny home system and a 2kW toilet

    The test home belongs to Cari, who lives off-grid in a tiny home and has been running a Cinderella Freedom. The Freedom burns LPG to incinerate and only draws around 1.3 amps at 12V while it runs, so it barely registers on a solar system. Cari wanted to know if she could swap to the all-electric Cinderella Comfort instead.

    Cari's system
    Solar array 6kW
    Battery 13kWh
    Inverter 5kW
    Designed by Cyrus Energy

    The Comfort is a 2kW appliance that uses about 1.41kWh per incineration cycle. That's roughly the same energy as running a 2kW heater for 40 minutes, every time someone uses the loo. Ecoash brought a Comfort out to Cari's place, ran test cycles, and watched the system through its monitoring app before, during and after.

    What the test showed

    The system ran the Comfort alongside a toaster and washing machine, and the battery was back to 100% by mid-afternoon.

    Battery dipped about 4 points while the toilet ran, then refilled to 100% by mid-afternoon

    Battery state of charge, 13kWh battery, sunny test day

    Battery state of charge across the test day Start of test 85.7% (11.5kWh, solar 1.9kW, load 1.9kW). 11:28am 81.7% (10.97kWh, solar 2.1kW, load 2.1kW). Midday 81.9% (10.99kWh, solar 2.3kW, load 2.1kW). 1:26pm 88.9% (11.94kWh, solar 2.4kW, load 0.1kW). Mid-afternoon 100% (13.43kWh, battery full). 100% 95% 90% 85% 80% 75% Start level 85.7% 85.7% 81.7% 81.9% 88.9% 100% 11.5kWh 10.97kWh 10.99kWh 11.94kWh 13.43kWh Start of test 11:28am Midday 1:26pm Mid-afternoon Solar 1.9kW, load 1.9kW Solar 2.1kW, load 2.1kW Solar 2.3kW, load 2.1kW Solar 2.4kW, load 0.1kW Battery full
    Ecoash test results, Cari's off-grid tiny home. Start and mid-afternoon times approximate.

    Through the morning, solar output roughly matched what the house was using, so the battery only slipped from 85.7% to 81.7%. Once the toaster and washing machine finished and the house load dropped to almost nothing, the 6kW array put around 2.3kW straight back into the battery.

    Our take: it works, but size for winter evenings, not sunny mornings

    The test is a good result, but it was run on a sunny day with the toilet used while the panels were pumping. In those conditions the solar carried almost all of the load, and the battery only dropped about half a kWh across the whole morning. The harder test is a grey July evening, when every cycle comes straight out of the battery.

    So here's the maths we'd do before anyone swaps from LPG. Every cycle is about 1.41kWh, and it adds up fast:

    Cycles a day Extra energy a day Share of a 13kWh battery
    2 2.8kWh 22%
    4 5.6kWh 43%
    6 8.5kWh 65%

    A couple using it four times a day between them is adding around 5.6kWh a day, which can be as much as the rest of a tiny home uses. On a dull winter day, when a 6kW array might only make a fraction of its summer output, that's the difference between getting through the night and the battery running flat.

    The inverter matters too. The toilet pulls 2kW on its own. Boil a 2.2kW jug while it's running and you're at 4.2kW before the fridge, lights or a toaster come on. A 5kW inverter like Cari's handles that, but anything smaller will trip on overload sooner or later.

    The advice to run the toilet while the sun's out makes sense on paper, but you can't really schedule nature. Plan for evening and overnight use, and treat sunny day running as a bonus.

    Before you switch: five things to check

    1. Inverter headroom. Add 2kW for the toilet to the biggest loads you run at the same time (jug, toaster, washing machine, heater). If that total is near your inverter's continuous rating, it's too small.
    2. Usable battery. Work out how many cycles a day your household will actually do, multiply by 1.41kWh, and check the battery can carry that plus your normal overnight use without dropping below about 20%.
    3. Winter solar. Ask what your array makes on a short, overcast winter day, not the annual average. That's the day that decides whether this works.
    4. A backup plan. A generator input with auto start, or keeping the LPG Freedom as a fallback, saves a cold surprise in a long run of bad weather.
    5. Monitoring. Make sure you can see battery state of charge and load on your phone, so you can watch what the toilet is really costing you for the first few weeks.

    If you're not sure about any of these, have your solar supplier or electrician run the numbers before you buy.

    Where an Energy Hub fits

    Our Energy Hub Mini with 10kWh of SOK LiFePO4 would work for one person doing a couple of cycles a day, but with two or more people the toilet alone can chew through over half the battery, and a grey winter week would leave it short.

    The one that suits it is our Energy Hub Slim, which is coming soon. It's a complete off grid solar system in one cabinet, with a 6kVA Victron Multi RS inverter, 20kWh of SOK LiFePO4 battery, up to 6kW of solar input, generator auto start and remote monitoring, pre-wired and tested before it leaves us. The 6kVA inverter has plenty of headroom for a 2kW toilet plus the jug, and the monitoring lets you see exactly what each cycle costs you.

    If you're planning heavy toilet use or a bigger household, talk to us before you buy and we'll size the battery and solar around how you actually live. Try our battery calculator for a starting point, or give us a call.

    Thanks

    Thanks to Ecoash for sharing their test results, and to Cari for letting them test in her home. Her system was designed by Aydin Sadrzadeh of Cyrus Energy. For help choosing a Cinderella toilet, talk to Ecoash.

    Written by

    Brendon Shervell

    Brendon helps New Zealanders size and set up lithium battery and solar systems at Sogen Energy.

    More from the blog

    Still have questions?

    Got a question about your own setup? Our team can help.